STOP 12 / 31A big percentage needs a denominator.
Layout
STOP 12 · Signal

A big percentage needs a denominator.

EXPLORE~4 min
Back to route map
  • Last November, Northstar’s site went down during its biggest sale.
  • This November’s 70% year-over-year growth may mostly be recovery from an unusually low base—not new explosive demand.
Base effects: concepts and Northstar examples. Illustrative Northstar examples, not measured business results.
ConceptWhat it meansNorthstar example
Read the numerator and denominator.
  • Growth rates depend on both periods.
  • An outage, stockout, moving event, or accounting change in the base period can distort the comparison.

If last year's Black Friday checkout outage depressed sales, this year's large growth rate partly describes the unusually low comparison base.

Check more than one year.
  • Look at actual levels, two-year growth, and event-aligned comparisons.
  • Annotate shocks rather than silently erasing inconvenient observations.

Northstar compares event-aligned sales levels across several years before extending one dramatic year-over-year percentage into next year's plan.

Demand is not always observed sales.
  • Stockouts cap sales.
  • A model trained on constrained sales can learn that demand is low when availability was actually the problem.
  • A product selling zero units while out of stock does not imply zero demand.
  • Availability constraints must be distinguished from customer interest.
FIG 12.1

Change the base. Change the headline.

WHAT THIS SHOWS

Keep this year's Northstar sales fixed and change the prior-year comparison value.

The question it answers: Is the growth headline describing new demand or an unusually weak base?

Last year$30K
This year$40K
Reported YoY growth33.3%
This year’s sales$40k · unchanged

Reduce last year’s sales to simulate an outage. The headline growth rate rockets upward—even though this year’s result hasn’t moved at all.

Fine print & assumptions

Constructed teaching data and illustrative calculations, not a production forecasting service. Read the diagram's method notes and distinguish supplied simulator components from fitted estimates.

CHECK YOURSELF · CHOOSE AN ANSWER

Last year’s sale had a severe outage. This year’s huge growth most directly suggests…

Your learning note

Private · just for you