STOP 06 / 31Growth needs a fair comparison.
Layout
STOP 06 · Measuring

Growth needs a fair comparison.

EXPLORE~5 min
Back to route map
  • A 40% jump from October to November does not mean Northstar is growing 40% every month.
  • That comparison mixes business growth with the holiday season.
Choosing a growth rate. Illustrative Northstar examples, not measured business results.
Growth ruleWhat it meansNorthstar example
Average all months

Stable and smooths random variation, but adapts slowly to a changing rate.

Use Northstar's past comparable-month YoY rates when they fluctuate around a reasonably stable level.

Recent months

Adapts to acceleration or slowdown with less averaging; can be noisier.

Northstar considers the last three available YoY rates after a new market changes its growth pace.

Latest month

Reacts fastest, but one unusual observation can dominate.

A Northstar sale or weak comparison base can make the latest rate unrepresentative of next month.

year-over-year growth = current aligned sales / last year’s aligned sales − 1
FIG 06.1

A little growth goes a long way

WHAT THIS SHOWS

Northstar needs a growth assumption for next November. Compare observed year-over-year rates through October, select a rule using only those months, and test that rule on earlier months.

The question it answers: When does averaging growth smooth noise, and when does it lag a changing pattern?

This year's growth
Growth rate to apply
0%5%10%15%20%25%Apply 14.0%JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovNov: unseen

Backtest April–October · predict each month using only earlier rates

MethodMAE (pp)Bias (actual − chosen, pp)
Average all3.073.07
Last 3 months1.691.69
Latest month1.000.83
Chosen growth14.0%
November sales forecast · index114.0
November actual · indexHidden
Fine print & method

Two deliberately constructed YoY growth scenarios, not observed Northstar results. November's prior-year aligned sales index is supplied as 100. The November outcome is never used to select a rate or score the earlier backtests. The most recent method can be noisy; averaging is not universally right or wrong. Align weekdays/events and investigate base effects before applying growth to actual sales.

CHECK YOURSELF · CHOOSE AN ANSWER

What is the main danger of annualizing the October-to-November lift?

Your learning note

Private · just for you