- Northstar forecasts total sales, categories, and regions.
- Forecasts built independently can disagree: the category totals may not sum to the company forecast.
| Approach | What it means | Northstar example |
|---|---|---|
| Independent | Forecast the company and each category separately; their totals need not agree. | Northstar's supplied Home, Electronics, and Apparel forecasts sum to $109k while the company forecast says $115k. |
| Bottom-up | Forecast the parts and add them to get the total. | Northstar keeps category detail but replaces the company's own forecast; noisy small categories can make the sum noisy. |
| Top-down | Forecast the total and allocate it using chosen shares. | Northstar's stable historical category shares may miss Apparel's newer growth or a change in shopping mix. |
| Reconciliation | Adjust forecasts across levels so aggregation constraints hold, using a specified weighting/covariance model. |
|
Do the forecasts add up?
Home, Electronics, and Apparel have their own forecasts, alongside a separately modeled company total. Compare leaving them independent, adding parts upward, splitting the total downward, and reconciling all levels.
The question it answers: How can Northstar's category forecasts agree with its company forecast?
Parts add to $109,000 · total $115,000 · gap $6,000
Fine print & method
All dollar forecasts are supplied teaching values. Top-down uses fixed historical shares of 50%, 30%, and 20%, not the current category forecasts. Reconciliation is a weighted least-squares projection with supplied diagonal variances [4,1,1,2], not a fitted MinT covariance estimate. Consistency does not guarantee greater accuracy; evaluate that out of sample.